The Search For The Best Portable Hard Drive

February 2009

Walk through the computer department at the local big box store, and you’ll be greeted with a veritable flood of little, USB-powered rectangles begging to be crammed full of your photos. Which ones deserve a spot on your bag? We took a look at some of the most popular options, filled them with some files and admired them from our desk chairs. In the end, it all comes down to personal preference.


Imation Apollo Expert UX, $119 and up
Storage options: 250GB, 320 GB, 500GB
Storage Tested: 500GB

Good: There are only a few white lights to let you know it’s working, rather than an annoying, blinking Pink Floyd laser show on some back-ups. The “Live Backup” and “Imation Button Manager” software is easy to install and customize; The Drive Gauge, which is a meter in your right taskbar, is a simple way of checking how much storage you have left; It’s light and portable. The three-year warranty is also above average.

Bad: Despite the software’s ease of use, we still found it faster and more convenient to explore the C drive and drag and drop the files we wanted to move.

Looks: The best part of the whole drive. The Apollo Expert UX has incredible style. The most innovative feature is the oblong-shaped integrated stand that allows horizontal or vertical placement. It also comes with a diagonally-stripped rubber case to prevent scratching.

Verdict: This is a great-looking and sturdy drive that provides ample storage, fast transfer and portability all in a device that could be considered a work of modern art.


Western Digital My Passport Elite, $179
Storage options: 250GB, 320GB, 400GB and 500GB
Storage tested: 500GB

Good: The included back-up software is fairly robust, even offering some utilities that don’t actually apply to the drive itself, like allowing you to back up your e-mail contacts onto your iPod. It also allows for remote access if you’re a MioNet user. The included Sync software is also pretty handy if you move around from computer to computer a lot and don’t want cyber bad guys poking through your beach pictures or worse.

Bad All those features come at a price, making the WD one of the more expensive drives in the test.

Looks: There are six color options to choose from, each coming with a “luxurious” soft-touch finish that makes them easier to grip. When sitting on a desk, it almost looks like a wallet because it’s so flat and smooth. That’s definitely a good thing.

Verdict: While you’re paying a little more, you’re also getting a little extra. If you’re only going to use one drive across many computers, this is a great pick.


Seagate FreeAgent Go, $129
Storage options: 250GB, 320GB and 500GB
Storage tested: 500GB

Good: The Seagate name carries a lot of weight in the hard drive world because they have been making quality hard drives for a long time. The FreeAgent Go feels extremely solid in the hand and comes with an adequate suite of easily-installed software including a sync system and basic encryption tools. The 5400 RPM drive is fast and quiet, regardless of whatever crazy angle it may find itself in on your desk.

Bad: If you’re a Mac user, you’re going to have to opt for the special Mac version, otherwise the software will serve only to take up space on your drive.

Looks: PC users can choose from up to 10 different colors, while Mac users get brushed metal and that’s it. It’s a very stylish-looking drive that doesn’t try to hide the fact that it’s a piece of computer hardware. It actually gets better looking when you put it in the dock (sold separately). Though it might not look good enough to warrant the extra expenditure.

Verdict: Seagate is standing behind this little drive 100%, releasing several peripherals for it to play nicely with. That makes is a great option for people who travel occasionally, but spend the majority of their time at one or two machines.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: